European Muslims face increased online and physical attacks
Imam A.* remembers a paint attack on his mosque in a small western German town: "Once, several years ago someone spray-painted huge swastikas right across our walls and windows," he remembers. It was just one of many. Have there been more in recent years? "I can answer that clearly in the affirmative," says the imam.
On a scale of one to ten, he used to estimate the extent of attacks and hatred at two – today he would say it was six or seven. (The cover picture above shows a mosque in Dormagen in 2014, not the mosque mentioned in the text. The full name of the imam and where he lives have been intentionally left out).
Islamophobia and anti-Semitism have become an everyday occurrence in Germany. The country's Interior Ministry registered 1,026 anti-Muslim attacks in 2020. These statistics are the official cases. Yet it is not only in Germany that Muslims are increasingly being targeted with hate and threats of violence. Online hate speech is particularly on the rise.
The Council of Europe's Special Representative on Antisemitic and Anti-Muslim Hatred, Daniel Holtgen, has been following up on reports from Muslim associations in eight European countries. The results are not comprehensive, he cautions, but they are the basis for further research and need to be followed up by the authorities in the countries in question.
Coarse, brutal language
The victims describe online hatred and threats to be just as real as everyday discrimination and verbal attacks on the streets, says Holtgen. Increasingly coarse and brutal language, unveiled threats to life and limb, calls for racist violence have all become facts of daily life for Muslims. "These are criminal actions. This has nothing to do with the right to free speech," he adds.
And such threats and intimidation take their toll, says Imam A. After the swastikas were painted on the walls of his mosque, instead of the usual 100 attendees, only 10 people came to Friday prayers that week, he remembers. Young Muslims in particular stayed away because they were afraid. A police investigation yielded nothing. The mosque later moved to a location where there is video surveillance on all sides of the building.
Imam A. says he regularly receives messages reading "Go home" or "there is no place for you here". "The letters are either typewritten or made of individual letters from newspaper headlines, cut out and pasted together. We get letters like that almost every day." Sometimes, Imam A. says they include cartoons depicting the Prophet Muhammad.
"Really dangerous statements"
Holtgen has found out why the majority of hate speech is not reported: the victims either don't know who to report it to or simply believe reporting it is pointless and won't really make a difference.
The majority of postings are made anonymously, which allows users to post racist and even dangerous comments without having to fear real repercussions. "The majority of hate mail is sent anonymously. But the inhibition threshold is sinking. It is increasingly considered acceptable, so to speak, to post really dangerous and racist statements on the Internet. That is very worrying," says Holtgen.
The Council of Europe's Special Representative says the Internet is too much of a legal vacuum and it encourages copycat perpetrators. The terrorist who attacked a synagogue in Halle in 2019 streamed his actions online, copying the procedure he had seen in the attack on a mosque just months before in Christchurch, New Zealand.
Holtgen points out that the first step to better controls was made with EU legislation late last year: it holds online platforms responsible for the content posted on them. "Now," he says, "we must make sure that these platforms actually adhere to the law."
A threat to democracy
The chairman of the Council of Muslims in Germany, Aiman Mazyek, agrees that online hatred is a "recent phenomenon". But the number of cases has skyrocketed.
In 2020 alone there were more than 1,000 criminal incidents and almost 150 physical attacks on mosques across Germany. Mazyek hopes the Council of Europe's survey will give fresh momentum to more decisive action against this kind of aggression. "Just like anti-Semitism and racism, the attacks on Muslims are an attack on freedom and democracy in our country," says Mazyek.
Holtgen is reluctant to make concrete assessments relating to the policies of different EU countries. But he singles out German Interior Minister Horst Seehofer for praise: the council of experts Seehofer established in September 2020 could be a model for other countries, he says. This independent council on Islamophobia is made up of 12 scholars tasked with analysing new expressions and changing forms of anti-Muslim sentiment and how they correspond to anti-Semitic and misanthropic tendencies in German society.
Holtgen stresses that the Council of Europe has probed only eight of the 47 Council members – but of these eight, several boast the largest Muslim communities: Germany, France, UK and Austria.
The European Commission on Racism and Intolerance (ECRI) is planning to publish concrete political recommendations within the next few months to give politicians guidelines for combatting anti-Semitism and Islamophobia.
Imam A. hopes that concrete suggestions may lead more politicians and journalists alike to just come and stop by his mosque in person. "We are not a black box. We are just part of society."
© Deutsche Welle 2021