"People will always find a way to access independent media"
Topics
Qantara: Although you have been repeatedly summoned for questioning over your journalistic coverage in the past, this is the first time prosecutors have taken a case against you to trial. What makes this different from previous instances of pressure?
Lina Attalah: We still don't know what exactly triggered this escalation. We were summoned for interrogations by the prosecutor's office in the past and were then released on bail. But we have never been in a position where we were referred to court and faced a verdict as severe—the closure of Mada Masr and a substantial fine of over $50,000 [3 million Egyptian Pounds].
In the last couple of years, we were summoned because of specific publications. Once, for example, because of a piece about the conditions faced by prisoners and their demands for better. Another time, because we had published a story about allegations of corruption within a political party that is very close to the authorities.
So, the authorities are primarily concerned with critical reporting about Egypt?
Yes, in most cases. We were also summoned once for our reporting on the genocidal war in Gaza. This was at the beginning of the war, and the story focused on the pressure being put on Egypt over the displacement of Palestinians, which Egypt eventually offset with a very firm official position opposing the displacement.
How would you describe the current media landscape in Egypt?
The media today is subject to extensive control by the state. But this control has also created a sense of disorientation. The media's function is to inform people, to help them understand what is actually happening and what is at stake. When media outlets are entirely controlled by structures of power, something essential is missing, and they struggle to fulfil that function effectively. I don't even feel that they are being particularly effective in communicating the state's narratives. I believe that people are becoming increasingly upset by the lack of information.
Egyptians have, over time, also come to experience a degree of plurality in the media, especially in the mid-2000s, and it reached its peak in 2011 and 2012. You also have the internet, which effectively gives you that kind of openness. Being exposed to mainstream media that, for the most part, either says very little or simply repeats what the government says, has created this kind of misalignment.
When you founded Mada Masr in 2013, you set out to create an independent media outlet at a time of profound political transformation in Egypt. Looking back, how has the space for independent journalism changed since then?
I feel that what Mada has done over the last 13 years is basically to hold the space for this practice to continue in a context where it was almost completely disappearing. Very little independent media is left. Most newsrooms are either practising self-censorship or are directly controlled by the authorities. We've opened the way for information to flow more freely and for intelligent conversations about what's happening in our country and in the region.
Given that the Mada Masr website has been blocked in Egypt since 2017, how relevant can the newspaper realistically be to public debate inside the country?
We've been making it accessible through other technologies, such as mirror sites. I think we live in an age where people are very keen to access information. When there is a good, strong investigation or an important piece of reporting, or when a platform produces a great bulletin that gives you a capsule of everything you need to know on a daily basis, people will find a way to access that media.
Our audience has been steadily growing because of all these different outputs that people need. Mada's significance also comes from the fact that it has filled a certain gap in terms of the quality of information and the quality of the investigations it produces. This is what has allowed us to build an audience despite the blocking and despite all attempts to censor our content. Today, this is quite apparent in the solidarity we are receiving and in everything that is being shared about us.
"The Media Are PR Machines of the Military"
After being dismissed from the newspaper Egypt Independent, editor-in-chief Lina Attalah founded the alternative news website Mada Masr. Egyptian media are in "a very precarious condition", she says – and calls for a new kind of critical journalism. Interview by Jannis Hagmann
A couple of weeks before your detention in October, the entire newsroom of the fact-checking platform Matsadash was also arrested. The Egyptian authorities accused its journalists of being affiliated with the Muslim Brotherhood, which was banned in Egypt in 2013, allegations the platform has strongly denied. How do you interpret these accusations?
The current authorities came to power partly by bolstering the image of a clear enemy: the Muslim Brotherhood. They continue to invoke this image of the enemy for the legitimacy of their political project.
This accusation was extended to the newsroom of Matsadash, even though none of these young journalists has anything to do with the Muslim Brotherhood. In fact, some of their investigations have been quite incriminating toward the Muslim Brotherhood. The broader context is that there is no Muslim Brotherhood organisation operating in the country. As far as we know, its members are either in prison or have left the country. The six young men at Matsadash are simply young people who are interested in working as journalists. We know some of them, and we have actually trained some of them at Mada.
Both Mada Masr and Matsadash have continued their work for years despite censorship in Egypt. Why are they being targeted in this manner right now?
We don't know exactly, but there seems to be a decision coming from somewhere that these projects are no longer going to be tolerated. The country is going through political and economic challenges, and nobody should be reporting on these issues.
The state also says quite openly that the only thing you should report on certain events is the official statement, and that you are not allowed to go beyond those statements. There is a sense of wanting to create a monopoly over information.
Given the legal challenges you are facing, are you still able to do journalism, or has your work effectively come to a halt?
We have suspended most of our publishing activities in recent days, pending the appeal in the case in which the court ordered Mada Masr's closure. At the same time, we are exploring ways to continue our work within the law. We are very keen to resume publishing, but we want to be able to do so under legal protection. We are still trying to determine what kind of legal pathway would make that possible.
You could face a prison sentence of up to one year because of your journalistic work. What motivates you to carry on despite these risks?
We simply love this job. We are very fortunate to be in a position where we can try to unpack what's happening around us, reach out to sources and understand what is at stake. For us, all of this is actually exciting, because it makes us feel engaged. You have the agency to ask questions and try to find answers. You try to understand what's happening and share that understanding with your growing audience. That's what drives us to keep doing this work, even though it comes with many burdens and, currently, all these threats.
Another important element is being able to do this collectively, as part of a constantly changing group of intelligent journalists and reporters from different walks of life. All of this makes you feel privileged to do this work.
© Qantara.de