''Egypt Doesn't Need Dollars, It Needs a Clear Plan''

Egyptian entrepreneur and publisher Saleh Diab is concerned over the future of his country. Foreign investors are being discouraged by political conditions, and the nation lacks a vision for the future, he says. Interview by Kersten Knipp

الكاتبة ، الكاتب: Kersten Knipp

Mr Diab, you own one of Egypt's most influential daily newspapers, the "Al Masry al Youm". Its sister paper is the English-language weekly "Egypt Independent". How would you describe the publication's ideological position?

Saleh Diab: It's an independent newspaper committed to representing the interests of all Egyptians. It exposes malpractice, but also tries to present solutions and ideas. This is why the paper is viewed by those in power – regardless of who that might be – as a platform for the opposition.

Government representatives essentially perceive criticism as opposition. That was the case for the Mubarak regime, and it's the same for the Muslim Brotherhood now. They see us as an adversarial publication – and not as one that considers the welfare of all Egyptians. Of course we're critical. Because good flourishes by itself, we would rather focus our attentions on the nation's problems.

Climate of uncertainty: "Entrepreneurs are leaving the country. And if even Egyptians are leaving – why should investors come in from elsewhere?"

What's your view of the country's current political and economic climate?

Saleh Diab: The media enjoyed relative freedom under Mubarak. There was plenty to criticise back then. But today, everything must be viewed with a critical eye, at least much more than before. Take, for instance, president Mohamed Morsi's speeches: They are extremely vague, just like the accusations he makes.

For example, he claims there are 30 or 40 families in Egypt controlling the wealth of the nation. But if you ask the Egyptians themselves who's dominating the nation's economy, they'll reel off a long list of names.

Morsi on the other hand points at several individuals whom he says are trying to influence Egypt's political landscape and stability. But at the same time, he's not accommodating the needs of the Egyptian business community. That's why entrepreneurs are leaving the country. In view of this development, foreign investors cannot be convinced to invest here.

If even Egyptians are leaving – why should investors come in from elsewhere? This climate of uncertainty is a key contributing factor in the economic catastrophe facing the country.

The Egyptian economy is in tatters. IMF loan negotiations have just broken down. The country's official unemployment rate is 13 percent, but in the 14-29 age group it's over 70 percent. How do you view the nation's economic future?

Saleh Diab: The problem is no one was ready for the revolution. The Mubarak regime didn't expect it, and neither did the opposition. Even the Muslim Brotherhood was taken by surprise. But there's something else: We don't have a model to guide us.

"We don't need billion-dollar aid packages. What we need is a plan, a clear vision of the future," says Saleh Diab. The country's official unemployment rate is 13 percent, but in the 14-29 age group it's over 70 percent

Environmental and human rights issues, the banking sector – hardly anyone knows how we should be tackling these challenges. That's why we need a politician with a clear concept for the nation's future. East Germany was able to orientate itself with West Germany post-1989. We don't have a model like this.

What does this mean for the future of the nation?

Saleh Diab: The future of Egypt depends on how the nation's problems are dealt with. Things simply can't carry on as they are; the problems are so large no one can ignore them anymore. They are having an impact on each and every Egyptian. We're seeing unprecedented rates of inflation. We're experiencing unprecedented chaos, as well as a new security problem. The issue is that although the leadership has been replaced, the old structures are still in place.

Can the West help Egypt shape its future?

Saleh Diab: The West can help by advising Egypt on how to shape its future – by acquainting Egypt with EU institutions, for example. We don't need billion-dollar aid packages. The funds would be used up within a month – perhaps even two weeks. What we need is a plan, a clear vision of the future. We don't need any dollars – after all, we're better practised than most at squandering those dollars. As long as we don't have a plan, financial aid is pointless. We need a model, a formula that we can pursue.

Interview by Kersten Knipp

Saleh Diab is Managing Director of the PICO Group, a company mainly active in the energy and agricultural sectors. He is also the owner of "Al Masry al Yaum", one of Egypt's most influential daily newspapers.

Translation: Nina Coon

Qantara.de editor: Lewis Gropp